Guard llamas and what the internet won’t tell you.

In addition to the twenty-eight llamas and alpacas at our place, Jeremiah shears roughly a dozen llamas and alpacas for other people. Some of them are better than others. A few stand as well as our own. Several fuss a bit. (I have a few who do that as well.) And a few of them full on freak during shearing. Thanks to one of those “freak out” llamas, I’m sporting several black and blue bruises and a now fading rope burn.

This weekend, I travelled to Northern Illinois with Jeremiah to shear three guard llamas. These particular llamas belong to wonderful sheep ranchers who had employed him last year for the same task. The owners are proactive about their livestock. They take excellent care of their sheep. And, up until my visit, they were largely misinformed about their llamas. In my opinion, their misinformation was perpetuated by the animals’ breeder, either unintentionally due to their own ignorance or intentionally to ensure easy sales.

For those of you who may not know, llamas are often “employed” to guard other livestock. They regularly guard sheep, goats, alpacas, etc, against natural predators. Being strongly bonded herd animals, they can be exceptionally good at this work because they bond with other types of livestock and will consider them to be their herd. And llamas protect their herd. Llamas are especially noted for preventing coyotes from attacking lambs and kids in sheep and goat herds.

As often as not, people who get guard llamas know almost nothing about llamas. They depend on the people who they’re buying the llamas from, or the internet, to fill in sizable knowledge gaps. And as often as not, they do not get accurate information.

When we pulled up to the sheep barn, I noticed that only two of the llamas were haltered. The owners explained how they caught the two llamas laying the halters across the llamas’ food and fastened them while the llamas ate. The third could not be caught.

“So, you can’t approach them?”

“Well, you know, they’re guards.  So they aren’t supposed to be too friendly, and we’re not supposed to approach them…”

That right there…

The idea that guard llamas must, for some reason or another, be wild and crazy (or at least distant and unmanageable) is one of the most commonly perpetuated myths in the industry.  The idea behind it is that you don’t want your guards to bond to you.  They have to bond with the sheep, goats, etc.  As such, breeders often slate poorly trained or badly behaved animals for guard duty.  These animals often cannot be caught or handled without great difficultly.  They are practically impossible to shear.  You can’t trim their feet.  You can’t vet them.

Oh, and sometimes they throw me into a fence while I’m trying to help shear them.  And I don’t like that.

Let me be clear.  Llamas, even sheep and goat guards, should be manageable.  Training a llama to accept basic care and to lead will not magically remove its instinct to protect its herd, nor will such training magically bond your animal to you rather than its herd.

“Well, we were told not to handle them much by the breeder, and I didn’t see anything on the internet to contradict that…”

She had a point.  Most of the information out there about llama guards says that they should be largely left alone.  So lets bust some internet myths.

Myth 1: Guard llamas have to be mean to be effective.

Truth: Guard llamas have to bond to your herd to be effective.  They have to be alert to be effective.  They have to be adults to be effective.  They should not be mean or unmanageable.  They definitely shouldn’t perceive you as a threat to their herd.

Myth 2: All llamas make good guards.

Truth: Some llamas are not meant to be guards.  If you’re in search of a guard, look for a fully grown gelding or female.  Intact males should not guard other livestock; they will often try to breed them and could hurt them.  Former breeding males can also be a poor choice (for the same reason that currently intact males are).

Young animals (under two) should not be considered as guards.  Until that age, they are not fully grown.  They need to be big enough and confident enough to do the job you’re asking of them.  When they’re young, they should be protected by the herd, not the other way around, and it’s unfair to ask babies to protect babies.

Myth 3: If you want a llama to guard, you shouldn’t have other llamas around.

Truth: Llamas will guard together, but it’s probably best if you don’t buy a strongly bonded pair (such as mother and daughter) to guard together.

Myth 4: You don’t have to mess with a guard llama; just let them be.

Truth: This one falls in line with the “they should be mean” myth; “they should be mean,” but “don’t worry.  You don’t need to mess with them.”  However, just like all other livestock, they need vet care and worming.  Toenails need to be trimmed.  You have to shear them at least once a year, sometimes more often.  “Mean” guard llamas (and they are usually not truly mean so much as untrained) often have their basic care neglected because no one can get near them.

Guard llamas can be fantastic.  They will do a job for you, fending for your flocks of sheep or goats, sometimes even giving their own lives to defend your livestock against predators.  In return, they should be given quality care, and they should be trained so that care can be given without stressing out you or the animal.

Final note: One last thing people need to realize.  Llamas will protect their herd from predators.  Unless you socialize them to know the difference, they will not be able to tell the difference between coyotes and the family dog.  With proper socialization and training, the two species can and will happily co-exist.  Without it, dogs who the llamas perceive as threatening will be treated as such.  (And most guard size llamas are more than capable of killing Fluffy….)  Yet another reason to socialize and train your llamas.

Three of our girls. Aren’t they cute?

Oh – And for those of you who might be wondering, the sheep ranchers with the three llamas were very excited to learn that their llamas didn’t have to be difficult.  They want to send them to me one at a time this summer for some basic obedience lessons.

EDIT: Another llama mama out there (who has a lot of experience with herd guards) pointed out that even bonded pairs sometimes do well as guards.  It really just depends on the pair.  I should clarify.  Bonded or not, the llamas need to be interested in your herd.  If they’re interested, they will guard.  If they care more about each other, they might not guard well.



10 thoughts on “Guard llamas and what the internet won’t tell you.

  1. I appreciate this post!!! I have raised alpacas for 15 years and had two llamas, who have since passed away due to old age. They are wonderful animals and there is SO much misinformation out there. My llamas did guard, they worked together. One confronted the threat (usually a woodchuck), while the other lead everyone to the safety of the barn. The llamas were very effective at guarding but were very pleasant companions on a hike! The lesson is to select the person you are buying from very carefully!


    1. Thank you! You know, interestingly enough, my loudest warning cry when something is amiss comes from my littlest alpaca. She thinks she’s much bigger than she is and has appointed herself guard.
      …The llamas don’t take her very seriously.


  2. We have some friends who have alpacas, and one guard llama. When we visited Arianna watched us carefully and stood between us and the herd, until she decided we were okay. Then we were allowed to pet her and her charges. She is good at her job but likes attention too. We all hope to have alpacas and a llama someday. One of my daughters wants one of each color of alpaca! Thanks for posting this info to dispel the myths.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s